The 11 Best e Collars for German Shepherds in 2023

by Farmer Jack
Updated on

A German shepherd is sharp, brave, obedient, and muscular. It is no wonder then that the dog is known for serving in the military.

You may then be tempted to bring one home or you already have yours. We will have you know that dogs are naturally playful and curious so expect them to run after that ball in the park or bark at other dogs and strangers.

Of course, that kind of behavior is unwarranted if you have not commanded it and that is why you may want to get the best e collar for German shepherd.

With this resourceful device, you can train your pooch to stop barking unnecessarily and obey other commands.

Read on if you are interested in getting one. This review covers everything you need to know about shopping for a dog collar before parting with your money.

Best Electric E Collar for German Shepherd – Comparison Chart

The table below analyzes our top options when it comes to German shepherd electric collars. Why? Simply because we know that you may not have the time to go through the entire review or you just don’t want to.

This is our way of helping you make a fast and informed decision – you’re welcome.

1LED Light, Dog Training Collar with RemoteBlueCheck Price
2500 Yard SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers Range E-Collar by JUSTPETBlackCheck Price
33/4-Mile Waterproof High-Output Remote Dog Training Outdoor E-CollarsBlackCheck Price
4Mini Educator 1/2 Mile Remote Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training CollarYellowCheck Price
5Rechargeable Dog Training Collar, Dog Shock CollarCheck Price
61/2 Mile Remote Waterproof Dog Training Clicker Training Kit, E-CollarCheck Price
7Waterproof Remote 1/2 Mile Range Dog E-CollarCheck Price
8400-Yard Remote, Rechargeable Waterproof Dog Training E-CollarBlackCheck Price
92000 feet Range Remote Dog Training Collar with Shock Collar for DogsBlackCheck Price
10No-Shock Dog Training Collar with RemoteWhiteCheck Price
11Dog Training Collar for Large Breed, Dog Shock E-Collar with Beep VibrationBlackCheck Price

How to Pick the Perfect e Collar for German Shepherd

Picking an e dog collar for German shepherd is not going to be the easiest task. You have to consider several factors that will help you choose correctly. Here are some of those factors.

Responsibility and Safety

Most dog parents will tell you that they treat their pets like their own kids. Now, as a parent, you discipline your child not to harm them, but to correct their behavior. You want to apply this same notion to your pooch.

A shock collar is supposed to tame their undesirable behavior rather than hurt your dog. As such, you want to avoid conventional shock collars and go for something that vibrates or sounds an alarm.

Still on that, you want your training collar to come with different stimulation levels that you can apply accordingly.

Your Goals

Are you training your dog to stop barking or to hunt? Perhaps to work? You need to determine what you need a shock collar for before buying.

This way, you will be able to pick something that is exclusively made for the kind of training you intend to do.

Temperament and Size of Dog

You can bet that a training collar will not be effective if it does not fit your dog properly. In that regard, you want to take your dog’s measurements and use the dimensions against a sizing chart to get a collar.

If the collar is too tight, it may injure your dog or even restrict their breathing. If it is too loose, your dog will simply slip out of making it ineffective.

Ideally, the collar should fit snugly around your dog’s neck with enough space to slip in two fingers.

Effectiveness Range

It is important to determine how far you want your pooch to roam and still have its collar functioning. A mile range of 1/2 a mile is standard but it is okay to go for more.

Remember that a wider range is not an issue, but a little one could be. Moreover, you get to train your dog anywhere from the beach to your backyard when you have a wider range.

Collar Longevity

Surely, you cannot be looking forward to replacing your dog’s training collar often. It takes up your time and money.

To that effect, you want to pick one that is built to offer durability. By that, we mean that it should be made from a solid material that can withstand abuse from your dog as well as elements. Leather and nylon are good options.

Our Top Picks for The Best e Collar for German Shepherd

We know that you want the perfect e collar for training German shepherd and that is why we rounded up the top options to give you the following list. Whatever you puck from here will be worth your while.

1. Pet Resolve Electric E Collar

A shock collar is useless without a good battery because, then, how will the training work. This training collar comes with remarkable battery life and will give you enough runtime to make your training effective.

In case you prefer training your pooch outdoors, you will love this piece since it comes with a 3/4 mile range. As for your German shepherd, they will benefit from this collar seeing as it does not come with any allergic effects.

Last update on 2024-05-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

Sometimes, your pooch just wants to play in the rain or take a dip in the swimming pool and as a parent, you do not want to deny them that. Well, this training collar is waterproof so you can let your dog have some fun in the water without having to worry about it getting damaged.

As far as charging, this piece takes only 2 hours to fully charge and get this – you can charge it using an adaptor or USB cable. How convenient is that?

What we loved most however is that this collar allows for the training of multiple dogs simultaneously. This will come in handy if you have more than one dog.

What Could Have Been Better

The collar strap that comes with this training system is very long so it can but cut to suit the neck of your dog which although helpful, is a little bit of an inconvenience. You can change the collar strap to something else if you prefer that providing it fits the receiver.


  • Fast charging
  • Variable correction levels
  • Waterproof construction


  • The collar strap needs to be cut to suit your dog

2. SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Trainers

With a 500-yard range, you can use this training collar outdoors and it will still deliver amazing results. Do not even get us started on the fact that this e collar supports the training of up to 3 dogs at the same time. How cool is that?

You can also choose to train your dog using a beep, buzz, or static stimulation. These have levels to them as well.

Last update on 2024-05-09 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

Your dog can enjoy as much time as they want in water simply because this unit is waterproof. It also features rechargeable batteries that fully charge within 2 hours. You may also appreciate that it comes with a low battery indicator that alerts you of low power.

Another great thing about this collar is that it can fit dogs larger than 8 pounds with neck sizes of up to 22 inches. It is also suitable for dogs at any age so it can make the perfect e collar for your German shepherd puppy if you were ever in doubt about that.

We love that this product comes with a 1-year warranty. That says a lot about the manufacturer’s confidence in the product.

What Could Have Been Better

According to some users, this product’s charging plugs will not fit properly in their sockets. We feel that the manufacturer could have done better with the design.


  • Vibration strength
  • Wide wireless reach
  • Suitable for dogs of all ages


  • The design could be better

3. Dogtra 1900S –Training E-Collar

Perhaps you are a sucker for seamless designs? Dogtra has you covered with this unit. It comes with a slim and sleek receiver that allows for effortless wrapping of the strap around your dog’s neck as well as the receiver.

This unit is also IPX9K waterproof certified and what that means is that it passes the International Protection Marking system and can withstand liquid spraying at close range as well as a temperature of 176°F.

Last update on 2024-05-09 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

Whether you intend to carry out simple or complex training for your dog, this collar will help you do that. It comes with a 3/4-mile range that works for K-9 training to hunting.

You also get a whopping 127 simulation levels so there is no doubt that you will find one that works for your pooch.

We love that it comes with an LCD screen that is easy to read making operation easier.

What Could Have Been Better

As per some users, they did not receive the product in the product description. The manufacturer should have been transparent with that to avoid customer mistrust.


  • User friendly
  • Water-resistant
  • LCD screen


  • Confusing product description

4. Educator E-Collar Dog Training Collar

If your German shepherd is 5 pounds or larger, they will comfortably fit in this training collar as it comes with a receiver specifically designed to fit that.

The manufacturer of this training collar also had persons with small hands in mind when making the transmitter. This also works perfectly when you want to be discreet.

Last update on 2024-05-09 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

This shock collar will not harm your dog. Instead, it delivers a tapping sensation that is more like a vibration only that it is more intense making it extremely effective.

It also has stimulation levels up to 100 that you can choose to fit your dog’s temperament. Nevertheless, what we loved most is that this product comes with rechargeable batteries that take only two hours to charge fully.

What Could Have Been Better

Some users have complained that this unit stopped working after a while. We feel that the manufacturer should have made it with durability in mind.


  • Rechargeable batteries
  • Fast charging
  • Wide mile range


  • Not as durable

5. Duoai Dog Training Collar

Your pooch does not need a heavy collar or receiver weighing them down. It will only make them uncomfortable and anxious.

This training collar is quite thin and lightweight so you can rest assured that your dog will be comfortable and relaxed while wearing it.

Last update on 2024-05-14 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

This has to be arguably the best electric collar for German shepherds. How so? Simply because it will work whether or not there is an obstacle between your remote controller and your dog. This also means that you do not have to restrict your pooch to the indoors.

Moving on swiftly, this collar is adjustable making it possible for you to customize the fit. As far as the build material, we are looking at nylon, which is among the most durable materials available. You do not have to worry about replacing this one anytime soon.

You also do not have to worry about triggering the collar accidentally and scaring or punishing your dog because it comes with a security lock keypad to stop you from accidentally pushing the ‘on’ button. We love that.

What Could Have Been Better

Judging from reviews, the stimulation levels of this collar are not as strong hence not as effective. We feel that the manufacturer should have checked on this before releasing the product to the market.


  • Lightweight
  • Longer run time
  • Security lock keypad


  • Stimulation could be stronger

6. Ez Educator E-Collar – EZ-900

You get a bundle of 2 items with this product and with its wide mile range, it makes the perfect tool for training your pooch outdoors.

The training system is impact-resistant and waterproof so if you are looking for longevity, this could be your best bet.

Last update on 2024-04-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

It is a possibility that your German shepherd will stray and it is even worse when it happens at night. Fortunately, this training collar comes with an in-built light to help you locate your pet during such times.

What we found most appealing nonetheless is that this unit comes with 256 stimulation levels featuring vibration and tone. Imagine that! Surely, your pooch has to come out of this one properly trained.

What Could Have Been Better

This product comes with vague instructions as reported by some users. We feel that the manufacturer could have been clearer with them.


  • Remote controlled
  • In-built light
  • Strong vibration


  • Instructions could be clearer

7. Mini Educator E-Collar ET300

This product comes as a bundle of 3 items featuring an extra set of contact points and a clicker training kit. The system has up to 1/2-mile range making it ideal for outdoor training.

You will also appreciate that the collar is fully waterproof and get this – the remote floats in water. That means more water fun for your pooch!

Last update on 2024-04-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

The USA is known for producing quality products and this one is not an exception since it is assembled and tested there.

By using the clicker in the bundle, you get to teach your pooch new traits using positive reinforcement. The product is also extremely easy to use and we love that about it.

What Could Have Been Better

Some users have complained that this product scared their dogs rather than correct them. The manufacturer should have made the stimulation milder to avoid this.


  • Easy to use
  • Durable
  • Comes in different colors


  • Could be less harsh

8. DogtraiQ Plus – Dog Training E-Collar

With this dog training shock collar, you get a compact design that is perfect for smaller dogs. We are talking 10 pounds or more.

When it comes to the operation, you will be pleased to learn that you can use one hand. What’s more, you can use the remote controller without looking. It doesn’t get better than this.

Last update on 2024-04-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

You get a massive 100 levels of stimulations with this collar. We can assure you that you will have no issues getting the perfect level for your pooch.

Moving away from that, the transmitter features a selector switch that makes it expandable to accommodate two dogs. That is a win for you if you have more than one dog wouldn’t you agree?

We love that this product is produced under high-quality standards in South Korea to deliver the dependability and longevity that you would want out of a dog-training collar.

What Could Have Been Better

According to some users, this collar does not deliver consistent performance, which could compromise the effectiveness of dog training. We feel that the manufacturer should have checked on this before launching the product.


  • Expandable
  • One-handed operation
  • Compact design


  • Not as reliable

9. TBI Pro Dog Training Collar

If you are in the market for a collar with a wide remote range and a powerful processor, you have to consider this one. Together with independently functioning buttons that give an instant response, you can rely on training sessions with this collar to be fruitful.

You get 3 training modes with this collar as well as variable levels of stimulation and the best parts is that the collar is suitable for all dog sizes.

Last update on 2024-05-14 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

We want to believe that you would want to save energy if you had the chance. This product’s rechargeable battery is energy-saving and can give you up to 15 days of runtime.

The best part is that the battery takes only a mere 2 hours to fully charge. What we loved most nevertheless is that it comes with a protective mode to protect against accidental impact. It also helps that the collar is waterproof.

What Could Have Been Better

This product’s transmitter is quite blurry according to several users making it difficult to read. The manufacturer should have corrected this before allowing the product into the market.


  • Sleep mode
  • Waterproof
  • Energy-saving battery


  • Blurry display

10. Bousnic No-Shock Dog Training Collar

Training your German shepherd does not have to be a punishment. With this unit, you get a humane, safe, and effective training tool.

It comes with 3 training modes that easily capture your dog’s attention without hurting them. It is also sleek, compact, and lightweight making it perhaps the best-selling e collar for German shepherd puppy.

Last update on 2024-04-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

You would think that this product coming with a remote controller is enough but no – the remote is silicone-covered and ergonomically designed so that you have an easier time operating it.

That along with the 1000FT range, you get the ideal tool for carrying out your training sessions at the beach or the park.

We love that the collar is fitted with the newest lithium battery technology to give you longer runtime.

What Could Have Been Better

As reported by several users, this product arrived scratched. We feel that the manufacturer should have packaged it better to avoid this.


  • Lock feature
  • Convenient charging
  • Lightweight


  • Packaging could be better

11. iDOO Dog Training Collar

Your dog’s undesirable behaviors whether chewing, biting, or barking will surely be corrected with this training collar as it comes with 3 training modes.

Do not worry about the reach either because you get up to 1000 feet remote range. This means that you can train your dog anywhere from the woos to your backyard.

Last update on 2024-04-20 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

What We Liked About It

You no longer have to restrict your dog from swimming or jumping in the rain because this collar is water-resistant. That means that you can also do your training I the swimming pool or in the rain.

This product’s battery is also something we want to applaud because it gives you longer runtime and charges faster. As if that is not enough, it comes with a low battery indicator to let you know when you need to charge it.

However, what we loved most is that the collar comes with an easy-access button design making it extremely user friendly.

What Could Have Been Better

Regrettably, this collar will not fit larger dogs according to some users. The manufacturer should have made it adjustable to accommodate all dog sizes.


  • Easy to access buttons
  • User friendly
  • 3 training modes


  • Could be larger

Tips for Using a Shock Collar

There are different dog training methods but the electronic collar has to be the most controversial among them.

That said; most dog parents will resort to this strategy only because other training methods did not work for their dogs.

The good news is that you can use a shock collar effectively without hurting your pooch. Here are several tips to help you with that.

Showing is better than Telling

Most dogs will find the shock collar overwhelming and may also take some time to get accustomed to the experience. During this time, you are likely to go through a lot of awkwardness and confusion.

As such, it is important to be close to your dog to show them what you expect. For instance, you want to use the collar consistently to let your dog know that you do not appreciate their consistent barking. Whenever they obey commands, praise them, and even offer treats as a reward.

Allow them to get Accustomed to the Collar

It is important not to force the collar on your dog. Rather, you want them to get acclimated to it. First, you can attach it in such a way that only the prongs touch their skin and then wait to see if they show any signs of discomfort.

We would advise you to let the collar stay that way for about a week before fully incorporating it into your dog’s life. The problem with starting to use the collar immediately is that it will make your pooch think that the collar is the issue.

On the other hand, when you introduce them to the collar and begin using it later, they will know that their behavior is what causes the discomfort. Of course, that is the goal.

Do not Increase the Frequency for Faster Training

You probably think that using the shock collar often or even increasing the intensity of the collar will make training more effective but nothing could be further from the truth.

Doing that can cause your dog to start behaving awkwardly so you can see that it is a misconception. As such, you want to begin with lower levels and go at your dog’s pace.

While at it, you may also want to avoid showing your dog the collar as it can help prevent your dog from thinking that it is the reason behind their discomfort and unpleasant experience.

Switch to Milder Correction Levels Over Time

The perfect e collar for training German shepherd should come with different correction levels with the lowest being vibration.

Ideally, you want to start with higher correction levels and simmer down to the lowest. By doing so, you will get your dog to think that their good behavior is being rewarded. It will also motivate them to retain the good behavior. Remember that you ultimately want to stop using the collar. It is a correctional strategy, not something that your dog has to live with.

Safety Considerations When Using a Remote Dog Training Collar

Safety is paramount when it comes to using an electronic dog training collar. It is important to get professional advice – there is no substitute for that.

That said; we have some general safety rules to help you in the meantime.

1. Purchase your collar from a reputable company that is known for producing quality products. This reduces the chances of malfunction. You also want to read and understand the user manual that comes with the collar and pay attention to any warnings by the manufacturer.

2. Observe your dog’s response to the collar both mentally and physically. If you notice any negative reactions or implications, take it off right away.

3. Your shock collar of choice should only stimulate your dog’s muscle to the point of reflex to get their attention. Never at any point should the collar cause a sharp pain to the body or muscle.

Keep in mind that the collar is supposed to be used as a correctional tool and not one for punishing your dog whenever they misbehave.

4. The best way to get to a safe stimulation level is to start with the lowest and work your way up to one that you feel gets your dog’s attention. It could be something like a change in body language when tone or vibration is administered.

Note that there should be no visible signs of harm or pain such as yelping or growling.

5. Check to see if the collar company you intend to buy from provides all the necessary safety and training instructions. They should also have a functional customer service line for whenever you need help. You can always find out if this is the case from customer reviews.

6.You do not have to use the static stimulation function if your dog easily obeys orders. In place of that, you can use vibration or tone training modes. Simply put, shocking your dog should be the last resort.

The collar should be used as a temporary training tool until you go back to using gestures or verbal commands.

Frequently Asked Questions on GSD e Collars

You may have several questions that you want to be answered regarding the best e collar for German shepherd. Since we cannot address all of them here, we have tackled a few commonly asked ones that will give you a clearer insight.

Is a shock collar good for my German shepherd?

Yes, it is especially if you are having a hard time getting your dog to obey verbal commands. The shock collar gets your dog’s attention and works to stop them from displaying unwanted behavior.

You want to use the right level of stimulation though to ensure that your pooch does not end up hurt.

How do I punish my German shepherd?

The best way to do that is by rewarding their good behavior with treats and praises. We call that positive reinforcement. Do the opposite to discourage bad behavior but never physically harm or yell at them.

Do vibration collars work?

Yes, they do and they work perfectly to stop your dog from constantly barking. These collars can also be used to communicate with deaf dogs.

Our Top Pick

We have chosen the Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar. This collar comes with great battery life to give you hours of runtime for effective training. As if that is not enough, the collar charges fully within two hours and can be charged using either an adapter or USB.

It is waterproof as well and allows you to train multiple dogs at the same time. That is what we loved most about this e collar.


As a dog parent to a German shepherd, you want your pooch to behave, and training them should not take a lot from you because verbal commands may not always work.

A quality e collar for your GSD should capture the dog’s attention and get them to behave the way you want them to.

Now that you are equipped with all the information in this guide, picking the right one should not be a problem.

Photo of author

About the author

Farmer Jack


HayFarmGuy - Get Info About Farm Animals in Your Inbox