Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs Reviews, Features, & Buyer’s Guide

by Farmer Jack
Updated on

Looking for the best training collar for your stubborn dog? If yes, you probably already know how difficult it is to properly train a dog.

However, with the right training collar, you can train your naughty pooch to be well behaved. These devices are designed to provide you control over your pet without harming them.

But with so many options to choose from, how do you tell which one is the best for your pup? Well, to help you, we’ve compiled a list of some of the best training collar for stubborn dogs, including:

  • Features, pros, and cons of each collar
  • What to look out for
  • Frequently asked questions
  • Which is the best

So, check out the products shortlisted below and you can choose the best one for your furry friend.

Top Rated Training Collar Options for Stubborn Dogs – Comparison Table

When it comes to the best training collar for aggressive dogs, the choices are many. So, below is a quick overview of the features of some of the best products on the market.

RankProduct NameBrandWeight
1Waterproof Dog Training Collar with Remote, LED Night LightPet Resolve13.6 Ounces
2Pet Union Premium Dog Training Shock Collar 1200ft RangePet Union9.6 Ounces
3SportDOG Waterproof Remote Trainers – 500 Yard Range E-CollarSportDOG1.2 Pounds
4Dogtra 1900S Series Ergonomic 3/4-Mile WaterproofDogtra8.64 Ounces
5Garmin Delta XC Bundle, Base Style dog training deviceGarmin6 ounces
6Educator Yellow Color E-Collar Remote Dog Training CollarEducator7.68 Ounces
7SportDOG Brand Orange Color SportTrainer Remote TrainerSportDOG1.76 Ounces
8DT Systems Micro Dog Trainer Collar Receiver and TransmitterDT Systems1.6 Pounds
9PetSpy Dog Training Shock Collar for Dogs with Electric Shock VibrationPetSpy9 Ounces
10Bousnic Waterproof Dog Training Collar, Electric Shock CollarBousnic1.01 Pounds
11Rechargeable Dog Training Collar with Remote for Small, Medium, Large DogsTBI Pro5 Ounces

1. Pet Resolve Dog Training Collar

This training collar can restrain 2 to 3 dogs since it’s long enough thereby making it the best option to train and control your pets.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

During the night, it’s easy to use it since it has lights that help you see your actions. This trainer is made of high-quality material that makes it durable and you are assured of its good performance and long-lasting service.

More to that, the trainer’s long-range allows for training over large outdoor spaces and yards. It’s different vibration and shock levels provide a highly efficient way to prevent accidents and emergencies.

More Features and Benefits

In addition, you get to teach your pet various commands easily with just one button click. Also, you don’t have to worry about your dog getting wet since the collar is waterproof hence no damage in case it gets submerged in water.

Besides that, it’s always ready to use since it doesn’t allow standby mode. It’s important to note that the battery is rechargeable and it’s long-lasting. You need to know it has a 1-year warranty.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Warranty
  • Night-light
  • Multiple pet use

Cons

  • Excess shock may lead to depression

2. Pet Union PT0Z1 Premium Dog Training Shock Collar

Finding a training collar that saves power while you’re not using it is rare. This pet collar has an auto power protection system that cuts off power use when it’s idle. In addition, the fast-charging lithium batteries last for a long time before recharge.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

In addition, it has been fitted with a remote-control system that can reach up to 1,200 feet enabling you to have more freedom and control of your dog. More to that, you get a light mode that ensures you train even when there’s less or no light.

More Benefits and features

Besides that, its ease of use enables it to become suitable for both expert and first-time trainers. You get to enjoy the water-proof feature that makes it usable in water and rain without the risk of damage.

Its different modes ensure you use different functions effectively. For instance, the beep mode works best in training a dog to walk correctly whereas vibration mode trains against constant barking.

You need to know that the manufacturer offers free training once buyers make a purchase.

Pros

  • Anti-bark mode
  • Monitoring LCD screen
  • Long battery life
  • Free training

Cons

  • Prone to breakage

3. Sportdog 425X Remote Training Collar

The Sportdog collar has innovative technologies that make it a fantastic device. With along range of 500 yards, the trainer can be utilized to train 2 to 3 dogs with the same remote device.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Also, you shall enjoy its waterproof capability that is made possible due to its Drytek technology to work in wet conditions.

It’s equipped with large lithium-ion batteries that last for over 60 hours. More to that, the remote and receiver can indicate when the battery is running low ensuring you don’t get off-guard while training the dogs.

More Benefits and Features

You need to know that the collar has a detailed operating guide and customer care support to contact when you encounter problems during operation. Besides that, the buttons can be customized to function according to your liking.

Another advantage of this collar is its 7 levels of stimulation that you can switch between according to need. In addition, the hand transmitter consists of an OLED screen that enables you to read the selected dog, battery status, and stimulation levels.

It’s ideal for hunting or during training in the fields.

Pros

  • Drytek technology
  • High powered batteries
  • Low battery indicator
  • OLED screen

Cons

  • Costly

4. Dogtra 1900S Series 1900S Training Collar

A unique thing about this training collar is its seamless design that enables you to wrap the strap on the receiver and the dog’s neck without problems. Also, the collar trainer has an ergonomic design that allows it to be ideal on multiple occasions.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

In addition, it’s IPX9X certified as a waterproof dog training collar. Therefore, you will enjoy a long service time since it’s highly durable. Its three-quarter-mile range is essential in complex and simple training moments with your pet.

More Benefits and Features

Besides that, it’s a good training collar for K-9 training and pets with severe disobedience. More to that, the collar has over 100 stimulation levels that you can gradually change to find the perfect level for your dog.

Therefore, whether your dog is calm or very stubborn, the many stimulation levels will fit all kinds of dog personalities.

What’s more, the e-collar has constant and nick correction types. It’s easy to alert your dog due to its high-performance pager that provides clear vibrations for the dog to adhere to a command.

Pros

  • IPX9K waterproof certified
  • Slim and seamless design
  • High-performance pager
  • Many stimulation levels

Cons

  • Difficult to repair in case of damage

5. Garmin Delta XC Bundle – dog training Collar

This training collar is made for durability since it’s enhanced with a rugged, handheld controller that will ensure you use it for a long time. Also, a special side button shall ensure you have the option to increase levels of stimulation depending on your dog’s personality.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

In addition, you get the option of choosing the number of dogs being trained at a particular time. Therefore, you can do away with the unused trainers from the transmitter for better coordination.

More to that, you get the luxury of having short and long contacts. This means that whether your dog has long or short hair, it can be easily adjusted to be effective in delivering perfect skin contact.

More Features and Benefits

Besides that, the trainer has a bark limiter feature which helps reduce your dog from causing a nuisance in public. You’re given an option to use vibrations and stimulation levels that are efficient in stopping your dog from causing trouble.

You need to know that the training collar has 3 button configuration system aiding you to get wider stimulation levels that your dog will respond to properly.

Pros

  • Has both long and short contacts
  • Durable
  • High stimulation levels
  • 3 button configurations

Cons

  • Difficult to use

6. Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar

With a ½ mile range, this training collar is a good option if you are a pet owner of one dog. Its main unique feature is the control of stimulation technology that is advanced to allow you to change stimulations seamlessly depending on the dog’s temperament.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Also, its transmitter is ergonomically designed to ensure you’re comfortable if you have a small hand or while in moments that need discreetness.

More to that, the trainer has been designed to deliver tapping sensations on your dog to compliment and make stimulations effective.

Features and Benefits

You don’t need to worry about power outage while in the field since its lithium batteries that are rechargeable lasts for a long time. Besides that, the training collar has up to 100 stimulation levels for you to choose from.

In addition, the transmitter and receiver are waterproof making it ideal to be used in wet weather conditions. You need to know that it features a tracking light that enables the use of it during the night or in dimly light areas.

Pros

  • Ergonomically designed transmitter
  • Water and weatherproof
  • Shock resistant
  • High quality

Cons

  • Can only be used on one dog

7. Sportdog sports trainer Remote Training Collar

The electronic training collar gives you a long 500-yard range and the ability to train up to 3 dogs with a single remote transmitter as long as you get additional dog collars.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Besides that, the collar is suitable for dogs weighing 8 pounds with neck sizes between 5′ to 22′.

Also, the transmitter enables instant selection of 7 stimulation levels continuously or momentary. It’s equipped with the ability to vibrate and beep in case stimulation is not effective for your dog.

You will not have to worry about wet surfaces and weather since the Drytek technology keeps the remote training collar waterproof.

More Benefits and Features

In addition, its lithium-ion batteries give you a long service period and you will not have to worry about frequent recharging. More to that, the transmitter and receiver have an indicator that keeps battery levels in check.

You get the advantage of the manufacturer customizing the device according to your liking. The manufacturer provides support and customer care services in case you’re having difficulties operating the device.

Operating this training collar is easy since the brand provides a user guide.

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • 500-yard range
  • Rechargeable batteries
  • Low battery indicator

Cons

  • Some dog buttons may be inefficient

8. DT Systems IDT-Plus Micro Dog Trainer Collar

Both expert dog trainers and first-time trainers can use this dynamic collar that is very easy to use. Also, with additional separately purchased collars, you can train 2-3 dogs at the same time.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

The trainer is light-weight which reduces your chances of getting fatigued quickly. Besides that, the collar is compact and durable for a very long time. You will therefore get value for your money.

Besides that, the NiMH battery system comes in handy since it’s rechargeable and can last over 50 hours in the field.

More Benefits and Features

In addition, the training collar has a range of 900 yards. It’s, therefore, a good choice for training in the fields. The added safety shut-off system makes it possible to save energy when the device is not in use.

The trainer collar has 16 stimulation levels that can be adjusted according to need and the dog’s behavior. You can control it with one hand giving you maximum safety levels during use.

You need to know the manufacturer offers a 1-year warranty on the device.

Pros

  • 1-year warranty
  • Waterproof
  • Lightweight
  • Long 900-yard range

Cons

  • Range limits in thick vegetation

9. PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar

Petspy shock collar is a high-quality premium dog trainer that has been created to ensure maximum comfort for your dog’s comfortable use. It’s easy to use a training collar for new pet owners as well as expert trainers.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

You don’t have to worry about your dog’s negative reaction since this collar has 3 modes of training that can be used depending on the pet’s weight and skin sensitivity. You can use the beep, vibration, and electric modes to control the dog’s behavior.

Also, the buttons have been designed to enable you to distinguish them even without looking at them.

More Benefits and Features

More to that, It comes with 16 stimulation levels that can be adjusted depending on a dog’s personality. Besides that, you get an e-book copy that helps you watch training videos to get maximum results. Both transmitter and receiver recharge quickly at the same time since the trainer has a powerful adapter.

What’s more, it has a long 650-yard range making it perfect for use in the field.

Pros

  • Premium quality
  • Quick charging
  • Blind operation design
  • Trainer guide

Cons

  • Low sensitivity with long-haired dogs

10. Bousnic Dog Training Collar

A good dog training collar has different training modes and has a long reach. This electronic collar provides 3 training modes that are safe and effective including shock, vibration, and tone.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Also, it has a long range of up to 1000 feet that is made possible by the anti-jamming technology that offers stable signals. You can therefore use it in multiple areas including yards and fields.

More to that, the training collar is versatile since you can use its dual-channel to train 2 dogs at the same time.

More Benefits and Features

In addition, the collar has been manufactured with premium quality materials and has an ergonomic design to make it easy to handle and use. Its silicone prongs have been built by taking the safety of the dog’s coat into consideration.

Besides that, the receiver is waterproof and therefore you can use it in wet weather conditions. Its lithium batteries are rechargeable and last for more than 15 days after a full charge.

The collar is adjustable and protects your dog from the consistent shock that goes over 10 seconds.

Pros

  • Long battery life
  • Safe and effective
  • Ergonomic design
  • Durable

Cons

  • Requires silicone caps to avoid rashes on a dog

11. TBI Pro Dog Training Collar

This e-collar dog trainer is designed with a powerful processor that enables it to have a 2000 feet range to help you train your dog in the fields. Also, its independent buttons function with instant response to commands.

Last update on 2022-11-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

In addition, the different colors on the buttons prevent your chances of performing a wrong operation. Its 100 stimulation levels can be adjusted to effectively work depending on the dog’s temperament, behavior, or size.

Besides that, you get over 15 days of use for only 2 hours of charging. The lithium-ion batteries are energy-saving hence you will have reduced power use. Its energy-saving mode ensures that no energy is being used during idle time.

More Benefits and Features

More to that, the waterproof collar ensures your dog can walk on rain and water surfaces safely without getting shocked. Its smart technology reduces the probability of accidents occurring during training.

The collar has been developed by k-9 experts which makes it very reliable, safe, and efficient for different breeds of dogs. The trainer has been made to ensure your dog is safe during training to avoid hurting the dog.

Pros

  • High quality
  • Powerful processor
  • Rechargeable batteries
  • Waterproof collar

Cons

  • Not robust

What to Look Out for in the Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs

When choosing the best collar for your stubborn furry friend, there are various features you need to consider. This is because there are so many products out there and some of them don’t deliver on their claims. These features include:

Different Types of Collars

Training collars for stubborn dogs are available in different types. Depending on how stubborn your pup is, you can use the martingale or choke collars.

Martingale collars are gentler on dogs compared to choke collars. They offer you the reinforcement you need without being unduly harsh on your pup.

Choke collars, on the other hand, can harm your furry friend if not used correctly.

Shock Levels

Some dogs will behave properly with just a single shock. However, some pups are too stubborn and need more shocks to behave.

Therefore, if you’ve got a stubborn dog, we would recommend getting a collar with more shock levels. Also, the best product should allow you to customize the intensity of the shocks for optimal results.

Range

Another feature to consider is the range of the collar especially if you’ve got a big backyard. So, if you have a huge yard, you will need a device that boasts a higher range of coverage.

However, if you’ll be training your pup in a small area, don’t waste your money getting a long-range collar. A product with a working range of at least 300 yards will be enough.

Multiple Modes

Also, worth considering is the number of modes the training collar comes with. If you’re just starting to train your furry friend for the first time, a device with multiple modes is the best.

This feature enables you to find out which mode works best for your pup and you.

Battery

Training collars for dogs are powered by batteries. Therefore, it’s important that you invest in a product that runs on batteries with long power life.

Also, the best battery should have a full charge and low battery warning. More so, it should be easy to replace and have less charging time.

Waterproof

If water makes its way inside the collar, it can damage the device. For this reason, it’s important that you invest in a training collar that is water-resistant. This will allow your pooch to play freely even on the beach and can swim with the collar on.

Ease of Use

Another important factor to look out for is how easy the device is to use. Generally, you should invest in a collar that has easy to use buttons, an LCD screen, and dials.

Additionally, the unit should be easy to set new modes and levels. More so, an easy-to-use collar should have multiple controls for easy operation.

Why Use Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs? – Benefits

There are so many benefits that come with using the best training collar for your stubborn dog. These include:

1. The collars are the most affordable training tools for dogs

2. Offers instant feedback with a press of a button

3. Helps you fix your pup’s behavior from a distance

4. Effective when voice commands no longer work on your stubborn pet

5. Ensures your dog does not associate the negative reinforcement with you

6. The training works even when you’re gone

Disadvantages of Using a Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs

Like with any other device, training collars also come with some drawbacks if not used correctly and with care. They include:

1. It can destroy your relationship with the dog if it gets to know you’re behind the shock

2. The collar can be potentially used to hurt the dog

3. Relies on negative reinforcement to modify your pup’s behavior

High-Quality Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs Frequently Asked Questions

Below is a quick look at some of the frequently asked questions about the best collars for training stubborn dogs.

Q: Are shock collars safe for training stubborn dogs?

A: Yes, they are when used with proper care. You should adjust the shock intensity accordingly until where your pooch starts to respond to the commands.

Q: Do electric stimulations hurt dogs?

A: No, as long as you don’t overuse the stimulations.

Q: What level should I set my training collar?

A: It depends on your dog’s ability to respond to the electric stimulations. So, always start from zero and adjust the level until you find the best one for your pooch.

Best Pick Overall

Most of the e-Collar dog trainers have similar features. However, there is one product that outperforms the rest in terms of functionality and price.

In our view, the Pet Resolve Dog training collar is the best choice. Apart from its long-range, it is waterproof allowing you to use it on water surfaces. You save energy since it’s equipped with a standby mode to save power.

Also, the price is quite fair keeping in mind that you get a device with lighting to use for night lessons.

Bottom Line

It’s no secret that some dogs can be very stubborn and unruly. The good news is that with the best training collar for stubborn dogs, you can train your pooch in no time. Just make sure you understand your dog’s needs before purchasing any collar.

Photo of author

About the author

Farmer Jack